A chapter-by-chapter reply to Richard Dawkins
Author
Zain Mankani
Architect and psychologist passionate about Jungian psychology, dream interpretation, and symbolism; author of A Critique of The God Delusion.
The book
A Critique of The God Delusion
Dawkins' The God Delusion has been described as a "hard-hitting rebuttal" of religion. Its persuasive rhetoric tends to captivate younger readers, who may lack the critical skills to fully assess the evidence presented. Even more seasoned readers, aware of the fragility of Dawkins' arguments, often struggle to articulate exactly why they are weak and delusory.
This book meticulously examines Dawkins' claims, revealing the tenuous foundations upon which they rest. Every argument from the original work is carefully scrutinized and exposed as, at best, a mixture of misinformation and misrepresentation, or at worst, irrational, self-contradictory, and self-defeating.
This book is a great lesson in critical thinking and will empower young readers to confidently question, analyze and critique similar rhetoric wherever they encounter it.
Look inside
Turn through the pages.
A few pages from the book, so you can see how it reads before you buy.
1 / 6
Swipe, tap or use your arrow keys
The themes
What this book is about .
How an argument is built, and where it gives way
Reason and faith examined side by side
Carl Jung's place in a debate that mostly ignores him
What counts as evidence, and who gets to decide
Behind The Book
About the Author
Zain Mankani is an architect from Karachi. He has a deep interest in analytical psychology and dream interpretation. When he is not designing buildings or writing about architecture, he is interpreting dreams for his friends. His passion for Jungian (analytical) psychology also fuels his interest in symbolism, and in mythology and comparative religion. He has previously co-authored a book on Pakistani architects, and is currently working on one on dream interpretation.
Excerpts
Read a little of the book.
This book is not meant to offer proof of the existence of God. It is simply a critique of Richard Dawkins' book, The God Delusion. I started reading Dawkins' book in order to familiarize myself with the arguments of atheists. However, I found the arguments offered therein to be very weak and unable to withstand even the most rudimentary critical analysis.
Having said that, I bear no malice towards the author on the basis of his personal views. He has a right to believe what he wishes to believe and even to propagate those views, so long as those views are properly classified as opinions, rather than rational and scientific truths.
This book is, of course, written from the perspective of a Muslim. However, it is valuable for believers belonging to all faiths since it examines atheist arguments against all conceptions of the Divine and against all religions, and shows that these arguments are either weak, self-defeating or illogical.
Discover more authors
Writers published in Pakistan with us.
Abdul Aziz Ayub
View authorPhysiology lecturer, author of The Lost and the Broken, turned a COVID writing experiment into a passion for storytelling.
Abdullah Ali Khan
View authorAuthor, entrepreneur, and aspiring musician. Author of 'Being and Becoming' and 'Metamorphosis'.
Abdullah Bin Zubair
View authorUndergraduate student, exploring emotions through poetry. Author of 'The Gods We Cannot Be'.
Your book next
Could your story be next?
Every author here began by sending us their manuscript. Register as an author and take your first step.
Register as an author